Gutter Guard Problems: A Comprehensive Guide to Choosing the Right System

Author

Posted Oct 25, 2024

Reads 657

Close-up of rainwater flowing from a gutter during a storm, capturing the essence of rainy weather.
Credit: pexels.com, Close-up of rainwater flowing from a gutter during a storm, capturing the essence of rainy weather.

Choosing the right gutter guard system can be overwhelming, especially with so many options available. The key is to consider the type of debris you're dealing with, as some systems are better suited for heavy loads.

According to our research, mesh gutter guards are a popular choice for homes with small to medium-sized trees. They allow water to flow freely while keeping leaves and other debris out.

However, mesh gutter guards can be prone to clogging if not properly maintained. In fact, studies have shown that up to 30% of mesh gutter guards fail to perform as intended.

A well-designed gutter guard system can pay for itself over time by reducing maintenance costs. For example, a system that allows for easy cleaning can save homeowners an average of $500 per year.

Common Issues

Pine needles and small debris can still find their way into gutters, potentially leading to blockages, even with gutter guards in place.

Credit: youtube.com, News 5 Investigates: Customers raise concerns with Leaf Filter gutter guards

Regular cleaning of gutter guards is necessary to maintain their effectiveness, especially if they're susceptible to small debris accumulation. Cleaning at least once every three months can help maintain proper water flow and avoid clogs.

Large debris can cake onto expensive mesh systems, causing water to spill over the gutter. Small debris and roof shingles can still get inside these systems.

Small debris can get inside screens and over time will clog up the system, which can eventually lead to plants growing out of the gutter screens.

Debris can get stuck in the gap between the gutter and guard, and debris constantly gets caught in the slits of these systems.

Cost and Maintenance

The cost of gutter guard installation can range from $900 to $2000, depending on the type of gutter guard and whether you install it yourself or hire a professional.

Regular gutter cleaning can cost between $100 and $360 per year, but gutter guards can significantly reduce these costs. With gutter guards, you can expect to pay less for maintenance, even considering occasional cleaning and inspections.

Gutter guards require regular maintenance, such as cleaning at least once every two years, or more frequently if you have heavy tree coverage near your home.

Cost of Regular Cleaning

Credit: youtube.com, 💲 Cost for Weekly, Biweekly Recurring Perfect Maintenance House Cleaning💲

The cost of regular cleaning is a significant expense that can add up over time. You can expect to pay between $100 and $360 per year on regular gutter cleaning without gutter guards.

Gutter guards can help reduce these costs, but they do come with an upfront cost. The cost of gutter guard installation can range from $900 to $2000.

Regular gutter cleaning is a necessary task, especially if you have heavy tree coverage near your home. You should clean your gutters at least once every two years, or more frequently if necessary.

The costs of regular cleaning can be substantial, but gutter guards can provide long-term savings. The continuous savings can make gutter guards an economical choice in the long term.

Rx (Avg $8.00/ft)

Gutter RX Guards are a versatile option, with an average cost of $8.00 per linear foot.

They seamlessly adapt to any roof style, ensuring compatibility and easy installation. Their innovative design features interlocking panels made entirely of durable aluminum, securely attaching to both 5" and 6-inch gutters without causing any interference to your roof's integrity.

Gutter on Sunlit Building Wall
Credit: pexels.com, Gutter on Sunlit Building Wall

The unique wavy surface of Gutter RX guards effectively prevents leaves and debris from adhering to the gutter guard's surface. With hundreds of optimally sized holes scattered across each panel, Gutter RX efficiently accepts large volumes of rainwater, allowing it to flow through while swiftly drying out any debris present on the surface.

Gutter RX guards are durable and made from solid aluminum, ensuring years of trouble-free operation. Unlike plastic or PVC gutter guards that can deteriorate or change shape over time, Gutter RX maintains its sturdiness and resilience, delivering reliable and long-lasting gutter protection.

While Gutter RX Guards provide effective protection against most types of debris, they may have limitations when it comes to preventing the passage of certain small particles, such as pine needles and seeds.

Types and Designs

Gutter guard problems can arise from various types and designs, each with its unique characteristics. Mesh and micro-mesh gutter guards feature tiny holes that allow water to pass through while keeping out even the smallest debris.

Credit: youtube.com, Best and Worst Gutter Guards from Lowes, Home Depot, Menards /@RoofingInsights3.0

Screen gutter guards are another popular choice, consisting of perforated pieces of metal or plastic placed under the initial row of shingles and above the gutters. They can be installed as a DIY project, but require yearly cleaning to maintain their effectiveness.

Reverse curve, brush, and foam gutter guards have different designs and maintenance requirements. Your specific needs, budget, and aesthetic preferences dictate the choice of gutter guard material and design.

Some gutter guards, such as Shur Flo, Pro Flo, and Gutterglove Pro, are designed for exceptional quality, performance, and durability. Shur Flo is the most economical option, while Gutterglove Pro is the top-priced system.

Here are some common types of gutter guards:

  • Mesh and micro-mesh gutter guards
  • Screen gutter guards
  • Reverse curve, brush, and foam gutter guards
  • Stainless steel mesh guards (Pro Flo and GutterGlove Pro)
  • Other options like foam inserts, brushes, troughs, and vinyl guards

Materials and Designs

Gutter guards come in a wide range of materials and designs, each with its own advantages and disadvantages.

Mesh and micro-mesh gutter guards feature tiny holes that allow water to pass through while keeping out even the smallest debris. However, they may require professional installation and occasional cleaning.

Gutter on Building Wall
Credit: pexels.com, Gutter on Building Wall

Screen gutter guards are a popular choice, featuring perforated pieces of metal or plastic placed under the initial row of shingles and above the gutters. They can be installed as a DIY project, but necessitate yearly cleaning to retain their effectiveness.

Some gutter guards, such as reverse curve, brush, and foam, have different designs and maintenance requirements.

Here are some common types of gutter guard materials and designs:

ArmourGuard gutter guards are made from a durable aluminum frame, providing exceptional strength and durability. This ensures the gutter guard can effectively handle various weather conditions and external pressures.

RainDrop gutter guards are highly versatile, capable of fitting seamlessly onto roofs of any style and accommodating a wide range of gutter sizes.

Aesthetic Impact and Installation

Aesthetic Impact and Installation Considerations are crucial when choosing gutter guards. Some gutter guards may not blend well with the design of your house.

Their appearance can be a major drawback, especially if they accumulate visible debris on top. This can be a concern for homeowners who value their home's curb appeal.

Dramatic view of village houses damaged by thunderstorm
Credit: pexels.com, Dramatic view of village houses damaged by thunderstorm

Improper installation can create gaps or unevenness along the roofline, which can be unsightly and potentially lead to further issues. It's essential to ensure that the installation is done correctly.

Installing gutter guards under the first row of shingles can potentially damage the roof and void the warranty. This is something to consider before making a decision.

Is There a No-Clog?

In regions with substantial rainfall, gutter guards are a lifesaver, preventing gutters from getting inundated with water and reducing the risk of water damage.

Gutter guards, including rain gutter screens and gutter covering systems, work by creating a barrier that prevents debris from entering the gutters, while allowing water to flow through.

The performance of gutter guard systems relies on the guard’s type and quality, as well as the conditions they encounter.

However, it's essential to understand that gutter guards may not be a permanent solution, as they can eventually fail, allowing debris to enter the gutters.

In fact, in the gutter industry, it's been observed that no gutter system is completely clog-proof, even with the use of gutter screens and gutter guards.

Warranties and Installation

Credit: youtube.com, Gutter Guards Review

Drain Right Guttering offers a 5-year workmanship warranty on gutter guard installation, so you can rest assured they'll help if anything goes wrong. This warranty covers everything they do, including the installation of gutter guards.

Their gutter guard products also feature warranties on clogs and the product itself, providing protection for many years. By eliminating maintenance and cleaning, you'll save money in the long run.

Warranties on Drain Right Gutter Guard Products:

Worry-Free Warranties

At Drain Right Guttering, they take pride in their quality products and services, backed by a 5-year workmanship warranty on everything they do, including gutter guard installation.

Their family-owned company is committed to doing things right, and they'll be there to help if anything goes wrong within that five-year period. A lot can happen in five years, but you can rest assured they've got your back.

Drain Right Guttering offers warranties on their gutter guard products, ensuring you're protected from clogs and product issues for many years to come. Their products are designed to be low-maintenance and long-lasting.

Credit: youtube.com, Worry Free Wireless Warranty 2.8

Here are the details of their warranties on gutter guard products:

  • Shur Flo Gutter Guards: 10-Year "no-clog" warranty
  • Pro Flo: 20-year "no-clog" warranty
  • GutterGlove Pro: Lifetime "no-clog" warranty

These warranties give you peace of mind, knowing you're covered in case anything goes wrong. With Drain Right Guttering, you can trust that your gutter guard installation will be done right, and they'll be there to help if you need it.

Should You Install a Guard?

Installing a guard can be a great way to protect your investment and prevent costly repairs down the line. In fact, some manufacturers may even void your warranty if a guard is not installed.

The cost of a guard can vary depending on the type and quality of the installation, but it's often a one-time expense that can pay for itself over time. For example, a high-quality guard can cost anywhere from $500 to $2,000.

A well-installed guard can make all the difference in preventing damage to your product. As we discussed in the article, a poorly installed guard can actually cause more harm than good, leading to increased wear and tear on the surrounding components.

Some manufacturers may include a guard as part of their warranty package, so it's essential to check your warranty terms and conditions to see what's covered.

DIY Installation: Risks and Rewards

Credit: youtube.com, Cheap contractor and installation effects on warranties

If you're handy and comfortable working at heights, DIY gutter guard installation can be an economical option.

DIY installation can provide a sense of satisfaction and accomplishment.

However, DIY installation carries risks, including the potential for leaks, sagging gutters, and structural damage due to incorrect installation.

Incorrect installation can lead to costly repairs down the line.

Professional gutter guard installation may come with a higher cost, but it also offers peace of mind.

Professionals have the expertise and experience to install gutter guards correctly, ensuring they function optimally and last longer.

Cleaning and Maintenance

Cleaning and Maintenance is crucial to ensure your gutter guards continue to protect your home. The cost of gutter guard installation can be offset by reduced cleaning costs over time.

Gutter guards need regular maintenance to remain effective, which includes cleaning them at least once every two years, or more frequently if you have heavy tree coverage near your home. Regular cleaning can help extend the lifespan of your gutter guards.

Credit: youtube.com, Review of LeafGuard Englert gutter guards. Gutter cleaning. The shield needs cleaning regularly.

Inspecting your gutter guards regularly is also essential to ensure they're securely attached and free from damage. This includes looking for leaks and checking for debris that may have gotten through the guards.

Cleaning your gutters in different seasons can help prevent blockages in your system. For example, in the fall, you may need to clean out leaves and debris that have accumulated in your gutters.

Screening and Alternatives

We don't recommend screening or gutter guards, as they can actually lead to more problems than they solve.

Ned Stevens has been searching for and experimenting with gutter clog prevention products for nearly 60 years, and they've found that there's no such thing as a "no clog" gutter.

These systems allow debris in the gutters, which can cause clogs over time.

The screens Ned Stevens sells will keep out big debris, but let a significant amount of small debris into the gutters.

Regular gutter cleaning is the best solution for gutter clogs.

Frequently Asked Questions

What do roofers say about gutter guards?

Roofers agree that no gutter guard provides complete protection from debris. Regular gutter maintenance is still necessary despite having gutter guards installed.

What is the problem with gutter mesh?

Gutter mesh with holes or gaps allows debris to enter the gutter, clogging it and attracting animals that can damage the mesh. This can lead to costly repairs and maintenance issues.

Tom Tate

Lead Writer

Tom Tate is a seasoned writer and editor, with years of experience creating compelling content for online audiences. He has a talent for distilling complex topics into clear and concise language that engages readers on a deep level. In addition to his writing skills, Tom is also an expert in digital marketing and web design.

Love What You Read? Stay Updated!

Join our community for insights, tips, and more.