Gutter Guard Ratings Consumer Reports: Best Options for Your Home

If you're in the market for a new gutter guard, you're probably wondering which ones are worth the investment. According to Consumer Reports, some of the top-rated options include the LeafGuard by LeafGuard Home Protection and the Gutter Helmet by Gutter Helmet.

These two brands consistently rank high in Consumer Reports' tests, thanks to their effective debris-blocking and water-flowing abilities. The LeafGuard, in particular, stands out for its unique design that allows water to flow freely while keeping leaves and other debris out.

In Consumer Reports' tests, the Gutter Helmet and LeafGuard systems were able to withstand heavy rain and wind, with the LeafGuard system performing particularly well. This is a crucial factor to consider when choosing a gutter guard, as it can make a big difference in the long run.

The Gutter Helmet and LeafGuard systems are also relatively easy to install, with many homeowners able to do it themselves with a little bit of DIY know-how.

LeafFilter stands out as the best overall gutter guard thanks to its high-quality product, good reviews, and lifetime transferable warranty. Its gutter guards use a three-piece system with a 275-micron stainless steel micro-mesh screen that stops 99% of debris.

LeafFilter's warranty is rare in the industry and covers the replacement of your system or a full refund for the materials if there's a clog or overflow. Most companies only promise to clean your system in the event of a clog.

Gutter Guards America has an impressive product quality and selection of services, with a unique design and durable stainless steel micro-mesh screen. Its pricing is also reasonable and in line with industry standards.

However, Gutter Guards America's warranty and advertising are lacking, making it hard to gauge the actual value of the company's warranty. Its website doesn't show important warranty information, such as limitations and qualifications.

Choosing the right gutter guard can be a daunting task, but understanding the key factors to consider can make all the difference. The average cost of a gutter guard system for a 200 linear foot home is $5,000 to $7,000 for professional installation, or $200 to $1,000 for a DIY setup.

Material is a crucial aspect to consider, as it directly affects the longevity and performance of the gutter guard. Stainless steel is the best material due to its corrosion resistance, while plastic and foam materials are not recommended as they don't last long and perform poorly.

The type of gutter guard is also essential, with micro-mesh being the most effective type. It filters out the most debris, overflows the least, and is the easiest to clean. Standard mesh and perforated screen guards are not recommended, and while professional reverse-curve guards can work well, DIY versions are not advised.

A good warranty is also important, and for professional guards, a lifetime transferable warranty is ideal. This covers the gutter guards for the lifetime of your home and allows you to transfer it to new homeowners. For DIY guards, a warranty of at least 15 years is recommended.

Here's a breakdown of the key factors to consider when choosing a gutter guard:

There are several types of gutter guards that can help keep your gutters flowing freely. Brush gutter guards are a popular choice, especially for heavy rain, as they capture debris while allowing adequate water flow.

They come in standard lengths that can be cut into specific sizes and are easy to install and maintain. Some other notable features of brush gutter guards include their ability to prevent ascending rats in houses with downpipes and their suitability for homes with roof valleys and junctions.

Gutter screens, on the other hand, are made from metal or plastic and are designed to clip onto standard gutters. However, they require occasional cleaning, which can be difficult with some installation types, and their plastic versions can become brittle over time.

Here's a quick rundown of some common types of gutter guards:

LeafFilter is a type of gutter guard that's made from surgical-grade stainless steel, making it corrosion resistant. This ensures that your system will last for many years.

The LeafFilter system is patented, which sets it apart from other micromesh products. These products often use sub-par materials and can be installed in a way that's not safe, such as under your shingles.

LeafFilter guards are designed to prevent clogging, and they come with a lifetime warranty. This warranty is transferable, which means you can sell your home and the warranty stays with it.

One thing to consider is that LeafFilter is only available from one company, which may limit your options. Additionally, maintenance is often required, and the system must be professionally installed.

Here are some key features of LeafFilter:

However, it's worth noting that LeafFilter has received negative customer feedback for aggressive sales tactics. The average cost of LeafFilter is $5,528, which may be a significant investment for some homeowners.

Panel cover gutter guards are a reliable solution for keeping debris and pests out of gutters. They don't require a lot of maintenance or cleaning since no debris can get caught.

One of the benefits of panel cover gutter guards is that they are lightweight yet durable. This makes them easy to install and maintain.

Some panel cover gutter guards, like the Gutter Helmet, have a textured surface that increases rain-handling performance. This is a great feature for areas with heavy rainfall.

You don't have to climb a ladder to clean panel cover gutter guards, making them a convenient option. This is especially important for people who may not be comfortable with heights.

Panel cover gutter guards are easy to install by professionals with new or old gutters. This makes them a great option for homeowners who want a hassle-free installation process.

Panel cover gutter guards like the Gutter helmet are a great long-term solution for gutter protection. They can last for many years with minimal maintenance.

Some panel cover gutter guards, like the Gutter Helmet, are compatible with heated gutter systems like the Helmet Heat. This is a great feature for areas with cold winters, as it can help prevent ice dams from forming.

Brush gutter guards are a popular choice for homeowners, and for good reason. They're easy to install and simple to take out for occasional maintenance.

These guards fit inside gutters and capture debris while still allowing adequate water flow. This makes them a great option for heavy rain.

One of the key benefits of brush gutter guards is that they can be bent to any angle desired, which is convenient for homes with unique rooflines. They also come in standard lengths that can be cut into specific sizes.

If you're a new homeowner or a DIYer on a budget, brush gutter guards are a great option. They're affordable and easy to install, making them a great choice for those who want to save money.

Here are some key features of brush gutter guards:

Foam gutter guards are a popular choice for homeowners. They're made from UV-protected filter foam inserts that slide into the gutter and rest in its curve.

Water can easily penetrate the foam cells, allowing it to flow freely while debris is blown away by the wind. This makes them a great option for homes with round gutters.

Some of the key features of foam gutter guards include:

Screens are a popular type of gutter guard, and for good reason. They're relatively easy to install, and can be a cost-effective solution for homeowners.

Gutter screens are made from metal or plastic and are designed to fit inside the top of the gutter or clip onto standard gutters. They're a great option for leaf protection, but may not be the best choice for seeds or pine needles.

Some important things to consider when it comes to gutter screens include occasional cleaning, which can be difficult with some installation types. Additionally, plastic versions can become brittle over time and may need to be replaced.

One style of gutter screen, known as reverse curve gutter guards, protrudes in a curve over the gutter. This can make them vulnerable to damage from the elements.

Here are some key features of gutter screens:

• Gutter guard mesh screens are some of the best leaf protection for gutters, but not for seeds or pine needles

• These screens require occasional cleaning, which may prove difficult with some of the installation types

• The plastic versions can become brittle over time and need replacing

• One style, known as reverse curve gutter guards, protrudes in a curve over the gutter

• This makes them vulnerable to damage from the elements

The Amerimax Lock-in Gutter Guard is a good example of a high-quality gutter screen. It's easy to install and less noticeable than other options, making it a great choice for homeowners who want a low-profile gutter guard.

When evaluating gutter guard ratings, there are three key characteristics to consider. These are crucial factors that will determine the effectiveness and overall value of a gutter guard for your home.

Durability and material quality are top priorities. A well-made gutter guard will withstand various weather conditions and last for many years.

Effectiveness in debris prevention is another essential characteristic. You want a gutter guard that can keep leaves, twigs, and other debris out of your gutters.

Ease of installation and maintenance is also a critical factor. A gutter guard that's easy to install and maintain will save you time and hassle in the long run.

Here are the three key characteristics to consider in more detail:

Installing gutter guards can be a DIY-friendly project, but it's essential to consider the long-term usability of the material and the type of guard for your climate and weather. Most gutter guards should be professionally installed to ensure the best results, but some options like foam or brush guards can be done on your own.

Some gutter guards, like micro-mesh guards, are typically the gold standard, but only when made from metal. DIY guards made from PVC or plastic are more fragile and perform worse. It's crucial to be critical when choosing a DIY guard, as some perform poorly or are unsuitable for certain types of roofs.

Gutter guards should be easy to both access and clean, allowing you to ensure your home stays protected and dry. Some options, like micro mesh guards and brush guards, are easy to access and clean, while others, like foam gutters, are more difficult to maintain.

Installing gutter guards can be a DIY project, but it's essential to consider the pros and cons. Some gutter guard options, like foam or brush guards, can be installed by homeowners themselves.

Professional installation is recommended for most gutter guards, as it ensures a proper fit and reduces the risk of issues down the line. This is especially true for systems that require a transferable lifetime warranty, like Asher Lasting Exteriors' Gutter Helmet technology.

The main difference between professional and DIY gutter guards is the price. DIY guards are always cheaper, but they may not be as effective or last as long as professional options.

Professional installers offer longer warranties, better product quality, and the convenience of having someone install the guards for you. This is a major benefit, especially if you value your time and don't want to deal with gutter maintenance.

If you're comfortable working on a ladder and don't mind getting your hands dirty, installing DIY gutter guards might be a better option. Just keep in mind that these products are not as effective and don't last as long as professional options, which can lead to more frequent repairs and replacements.

Installing gutter guards can be a DIY-friendly task, but it's essential to consider the ease of installation. Some options, like foam or brush guards, can be installed on your own, but most require professional help.

Professional installation ensures the best results and cuts down on potential issues. According to Asher Lasting Exteriors, most gutter guards should be installed by a professional team.

DIY gutter guards can save you money, but they might not be as effective and durable as professional options. Waterlock Pro, Raptor, and A-M Gutter Guard are top DIY brands that offer micro-mesh and perforated screen gutter guards.

The Waterlock Pro has a heavy frame that won't fit every gutter and roof type, and it's the most expensive DIY brand in this article, with an average cost of $1,054.

Here's a comparison of the top DIY brands' ease of installation:

Keep in mind that these ratings are based on the helpfulness of included instruction materials and customer support channels, as DIY brands don't offer services like professional companies.

Ease of access and cleaning is crucial for your gutter guards. Your gutters should be easy to access and clean, or it's best to look into other options.

Some gutter guards are easier to clean than others. Micro mesh guards and brush guards are good examples of easy-to-clean options.

Foam gutters, on the other hand, can be a challenge to clean and maintain. They're among the most difficult to clean for long-lasting function.

Gutter guards like the Gutter Helmet block debris from entering the gutter in the first place, so cleaning is minimal. The only part that needs to be cleaned is the helmet's nose, which can be done from the ground without a ladder.