Gambrel Roof vs Mansard: A Comprehensive Guide to Roof Design and Costs

A gambrel roof and a mansard roof may look similar at first glance, but they have some key differences.

The gambrel roof has two slopes on each side, with the lower slope being steeper than the upper one. This design is often seen in barns and farmhouses.

A mansard roof, on the other hand, has four slopes, with two slopes on each side that meet at a right angle. This design is often used in Victorian-style homes.

Both roof designs can be used for various types of buildings, but they have different advantages and disadvantages.

Discover more: Designing a Roof Truss

A Gambrel roof features two slopes on each side, with the lower slope being steeper than the upper slope, creating a distinct bell-shaped curve.

This design maximizes attic space, offering potential for additional living areas or storage.

Discover more: Slope Shed Roof

The Gambrel roof is a design favorite for many homeowners, and for good reason. It features two slopes on each side, which creates a unique and functional space.

The lower slope is steeper than the upper slope, giving the roof its distinctive bell-shaped curve. This design is often referred to as a Dutch Colonial or barn-style roof.

A Gambrel roof maximizes attic space, offering potential for additional living areas or storage.

Consider reading: Roof Styles Gambrel

Types of Mansard Roofs are quite fascinating, and understanding them can help you make informed decisions about your home's design and structure.

One type is the Straight Mansard, which features a small top slope with a vertical lower slope, often with dormer windows for ventilation. This design provides a classic look and can be a great choice for homes with limited attic space.

The Convex Mansard is another popular type, characterized by a lower roof that curves outward like a bell, providing extra attic space. This design can be a great option for homes with large families or those who need extra storage.

Concave Mansard roofs, on the other hand, have a lower slope that curves inward, offering less space but a distinctive appearance. This design can be a great choice for homes with a more rustic or traditional look.

Lastly, the S-Shape Mansard combines convex and concave features, starting inward and finishing outward. This unique design can add a touch of elegance to your home's exterior.

You might enjoy: What Type of Plywood for Roof

Here are the different types of Mansard Roofs in a quick reference list:

Straight Mansard: Features a small top slope with a vertical lower slope, often with dormer windows for ventilation.Convex Mansard: The lower roof curves outward like a bell, providing extra attic space.Concave Mansard: The lower slope curves inward, offering less space but a distinctive appearance.S-Shape Mansard: Combines convex and concave features, starting inward and finishing outward.

Take a look at this: List of Roof Shapes

The Gambrel roof, also known as a Dutch Colonial or barn-style roof, features two slopes on each side. The lower slope is steeper than the upper slope, creating a distinct bell-shaped curve.

This design maximizes attic space, offering potential for additional living areas or storage. I've seen this design work well in older homes, where the extra space can be used as a cozy bedroom or office.

The Gambrel roof's design allows for a lot of flexibility in terms of layout and functionality. You can choose to add additional floors or use the space for storage, depending on your needs.

Gambrel roofs are often associated with traditional or rustic-style homes, but they can also be a great choice for modern homes looking for a unique touch.

Additional reading: Hip Roof Style

A convex mansard roof features an outward curve on its lower slope that looks like either an S or a bell. This unique design allows for additional interior space without the need for additional floor additions.

This type of design is most commonly used in the construction of courthouses. I've seen some beautiful examples of convex mansard roofs on old courthouses, and they always seem to add a touch of elegance.

One thing to keep in mind if you have a convex mansard roof is that you should remove all tree branches that have overhead and ones that are growing within five feet of the building. This will help prevent damage to your roof and ensure its longevity.

Convex mansard roofs can be found in various forms, including S-shapebell shape designs. Each of these shapes offers its own unique benefits and aesthetic appeal.

Explore further: Shape of the Roof

The advantages of gambrel roofs are numerous, and one of the most significant benefits is the increased living space they provide. The steep lower slope allows for more room in the attic, ideal for additional living spaces or storage.

Gambrel roofs are also cost-effective to construct, requiring less labor and materials compared to other roof types. This makes them a great option for homeowners on a budget.

Better drainage is another key advantage of gambrel roofs, thanks to their double-sloped design. This helps prevent damage from water accumulation.

The simple design of gambrel roofs also makes them easy to build, reducing labor costs and construction time. This is a major plus for homeowners who want to get into their new home quickly.

Here are some of the key advantages of gambrel roofs:

These benefits make gambrel roofs a popular choice for homeowners looking for a practical and stylish solution.

Mansard roofs have a low pitch, which makes them unsuitable for areas with extreme weather conditions. They won't cope well with heavy rainfall and can result in leakages.

The almost flat slope of the topmost part of a Mansard roof makes it prone to collapse under the weight of heavy snowfall.

See what others are reading: House with Mansard Roof

A Mansard roof's complexity of design leads to a high installation cost, often equivalent to installing multiple Gable or Hip roofs.

Not many roofing experts are familiar with the Mansard roof design, which can result in lower quality installations.

The high installation cost of a Mansard roof also translates to increased maintenance and repair costs.

Finding the right roofing expert to repair a Mansard roof can be a hassle, adding to the overall cost.

Dormer windows along the steeply raked bottom slope of a Mansard roof increase maintenance and repair costs even further.

Debris collects on the flatter portion of a Mansard roof, adding to the maintenance bill.

Explore further: Roofing a Gambrel Roof

A mansard roof can be a complex and costly installation, with prices ranging from $16,000 to $40,000 for a 2,000 sq. foot home.

The cost of a mansard roof is dependent on several factors, including the types of materials used, the size of the roof, and your home's geographic location.

Homeowners can expect to pay between $8 to $20 per square foot for a mansard roof, but this cost can increase if premium materials like slate shingles are used.

The construction of dormer windows can add to the cost, especially if you're converting your home to a mansard roof from a different roof style.

To get a more accurate estimate, it's best to use a Cost Calculator tool, such as the one recommended in the article.

Here's a rough breakdown of the costs associated with a mansard roof installation:

Keep in mind that these costs can vary depending on your home's specific specs, so it's essential to use a Cost Calculator tool to get a more accurate estimate.

A gambrel roof and a mansard roof may look similar, but they have some key differences. The gambrel roof has two slopes on each side, with the lower slope steeper than the upper one.

The mansard roof also has two slopes, but both slopes are relatively shallow. This design allows for more space in the attic area.

One of the main advantages of a gambrel roof is its ability to provide more living space. This is because the second slope of the roof can be used to create additional rooms or storage areas.

In contrast, a mansard roof is typically used to add height to a building without increasing the footprint. This makes it a popular choice for urban areas where space is limited.

The gambrel roof's steeper lower slope also allows for better water runoff, which can help to prevent water damage.

The Mansard roof has a rich history that dates back to the mid-16th century when Pierre Lescot first used the style in buildings across Europe.

François Mansart, a French architect, popularized the Mansard roof in the 17th century, and it became a staple in French Baroque architecture.

The Mansard roof was not just limited to France; it spread across the world and was adopted in buildings in the United States, Canada, and many other western countries during the reign of Napoleon the 3rd.

Interestingly, in Europe, Mansard can also refer to the attic space and not just the roof structure.

The Mansard roof became even more fashionable during the 19th century, especially in high-rise residential buildings, which featured the style in the late 1960s and 1970s.

It's worth noting that the Mansard roof was not as popular in traditional homes, but it was a common sight in many commercial buildings, especially those with a flat top.

Mansard roofs are more expensive to construct due to their complex design and skilled labor requirements.

Gambrel roofs, on the other hand, have limited insulation, making it challenging to keep heating and cooling costs down.

A mansard roof's unique shape limits material options, increasing costs. This is in contrast to Gambrel roofs, which have a more straightforward design.

The flat upper slope of a mansard roof makes it more susceptible to wind and snow damage. This can lead to leaks and even a collapse of the roof when too much water accumulates.

The complexity of a mansard roof's design requires more maintenance, especially for gutter cleaning and repairs. In fact, the use of dormer windows along the steeply raked bottom slope can push maintenance and repair costs to new highs.

Here are some key disadvantages of mansard roofs at a glance: