Cedar Roof Shingles vs Asphalt: A Comprehensive Comparison

Cedar roof shingles are a popular choice for homeowners due to their natural beauty and durability. They can last up to 30 years.

Asphalt shingles, on the other hand, are a more affordable option and are known for their ease of installation. They can last up to 20 years.

Cedar roof shingles are made from natural cedar wood and are resistant to rot and insects. This makes them a great choice for areas with high humidity or insect activity.

Asphalt shingles, however, are made from petroleum-based products and are more prone to damage from extreme weather conditions.

Cedar roof shingles are made from real wood and are known for their aesthetically pleasing appearance. They're usually thinner than traditional shakes and are sawn from a block of wood, giving a very uniform appearance.

There are two main types of cedar shingles: shingles and shakes. Shingles are sawn from a block of wood, while shakes are split on one or both sides, giving them a more rustic look.

Here are some key differences between cedar shingles and shakes:

Western red cedar is a popular choice for cedar shingles and shakes due to its abundance and natural resistance to decay.

Western red cedar is an abundant type of wood, making it a popular choice for cedar shingles and shakes.

The grain of Western red cedar is straight, which works well for split shingles and shakes.

This wood type has a unique appearance that many homeowners love.

Western red cedar is naturally resistant to decay, which means it can withstand the elements and last longer.

I've seen Western red cedar roofs that have been in great condition for decades, and it's a testament to its durability.

It's a great option for those who want a low-maintenance roof that requires less upkeep over time.

Western red cedar shingles and shakes can be easily installed, and their unique appearance adds a touch of elegance to any home.

Overall, Western red cedar is a fantastic choice for those looking for a beautiful and long-lasting cedar roof.

You might like: Shed Roof Wood

Alaskan Yellow is a durable choice for shakes and shingles due to its structure from the Cypress family.

It's not a species of Cedar, but that doesn't mean it's not a great option.

Alaskan Yellow contains tannins and oils that naturally prevent decay and mold.

This feature helps reduce the need for maintenance and provides a long-lasting roof.

Over time, Alaskan Yellow will change from pale yellow to gray.

Cedar roof shingles and asphalt shingles have some key differences that set them apart.

Cedar roof shingles are more durable and can last up to 30 years, whereas asphalt shingles typically last between 20 to 25 years.

One major advantage of cedar roof shingles is their resistance to rot and insect damage, which can extend their lifespan even further.

Asphalt shingles, on the other hand, are more prone to damage from heat and weather, which can cause them to curl and crack over time.

Cedar roof shingles also require less maintenance than asphalt shingles, as they don't need to be replaced as frequently.

Asphalt shingles, however, are generally cheaper to install and maintain, making them a more budget-friendly option for homeowners.

For another approach, see: Hail Damage on Asphalt Shingles

A well-built, properly maintained roof will reduce the effect of harsh atmospheric elements to the barest minimum.

Cedar shake roofs are recommended for those who don't mind a higher upfront cost, as they can be more expensive than asphalt shingle roofs.

Harsh Chicagoland elements like wind, rain, snow, and hail can affect the roof of homes, but a well-built roof will minimize the impact.

If budget isn't a concern, a cedar shake roof might be the right choice for those looking for a beautiful roof.

No roof will last forever, making the right choice on the type of roof to be used in your home a crucial decision.

Knowing the differences between cedar shake and asphalt shingle roofs can help you decide which type is right for your replacement.

A cedar shake roof might be right for you if you're looking to go all out for a beautiful roof.

A fresh viewpoint: Asphalt Roof Shingles Life Expectancy

Asphalt shingles are significantly less expensive than cedar shakes, with a cost of around $5.86 per square foot for a two-story house.

Cedar shake roofs, on the other hand, can cost more than 5 times more per square foot than asphalt roofs, making them a premium product.

While asphalt shingles offer the best price, cedar shakes provide better value for your money over the long term, lasting longer, performing better, and adding to your home's curb appeal.

Asphalt shingles are significantly less expensive than cedar shakes, making them a cost-effective choice for homeowners on a tight budget.

You can expect to pay more than 5 times more for a cedar shake roof than the cost of an asphalt roof, with prices ranging from $29.30 to $58.60 per square foot.

Asphalt shingles are the low-price leaders in the roofing industry, offering the best price upfront. However, cedar shakes are a premium product that can add significant value to your home.

A cedar shake roof can cost more than 5 times the cost of an asphalt roof, making asphalt shingles a more affordable option for homeowners.

While asphalt shingles may be cheaper upfront, cedar shakes can provide better value for your money over the long term due to their longer lifespan and improved performance.

Readers also liked: Metal Roofing vs Shingle Cost

A dimensional asphalt roof comes with a 30-year warranty once you remove the shingles from the package.

However, if you use all of one manufacturer's roofing components instead of mixing and matching from other companies, you can qualify to get the enhanced warranty.

The enhanced warranty covers your roof for the next 50 years, but be aware that improper roof installation or inadequate attic ventilation will void it.

A cedar shake roof, on the other hand, has no manufacturer material warranty because the cedar shakes are naturally made.

You'll have to rely on the workmanship warranty of the roofing contractor you hire, making hiring a great contractor crucial to your roof investment.

The warranty on an asphalt roof gives you peace of mind, knowing you're protected for decades to come.

Here's an interesting read: Roofing a Gambrel Roof

Maintenance and performance are crucial aspects to consider when deciding between a cedar roof and an asphalt roof. Both types of roofs require regular maintenance to ensure they last as long as possible.

Cedar shake roofs are considered high maintenance, requiring regular cleanings to prevent the growth of moss and algae. This can be a hassle, but it's essential to keep your gutters clean and debris off the roof to prevent damage.

Asphalt shingles, on the other hand, require low maintenance, but they can develop stains from algae growth. Occasional cleanings can help keep your roof looking new. Regular roof maintenance can also help catch any problems before they become major issues.

Both types of roofs can last around 30 years with proper maintenance, but cedar shake roofs have the potential to last longer. Cedar shakes are more resistant to insects, rot, and UV damage, but they can be prone to mold and mildew problems.

It's essential to keep your roof running smoothly throughout its life with regular maintenance, including yearly inspections and cleanings. This will help extend the lifespan of your roof and prevent costly repairs down the line.

Asphalt shingles can only perform well for 20-25 years, but they don't require any special maintenance.

A yearly inspection should be sufficient to ensure you get the best out of your asphalt roof.

Cedar shakes have a much stronger track record when it comes to longevity, lasting 30-50 years with proper maintenance.

They are also more impact and wind-resistant than asphalt shingles, but they do have a higher upfront cost and require more maintenance.

Cedar shake roofs require regular inspection and treatment to prevent problems related to mold and mildew.

Asphalt shingles tend to gather moss and are difficult to maintain, especially in areas with heavy rainfall.

Regular roof maintenance is crucial for both asphalt and cedar shake roofs to ensure they last as long as possible.

Cedar shake roofs allow for better airflow throughout your home, which is crucial to the longevity of your home, as it ensures moisture won't get trapped on your roof.

Cedar shake roofs are easier to install and remove than shingles, taking less effort and time to install, and even less effort to remove.

Cedar roof shingles have some significant disadvantages to consider. Moisture problems can arise, especially in wetter climates.

Cedar is more flammable than asphalt, especially if it's untreated. This can be a major concern in areas prone to wildfires.

The cost of cedar roof shingles is higher compared to asphalt, and installation requires more labor. This can add up quickly, making it a more expensive option overall.

Here's a quick comparison of the disadvantages of wood shingles: